The Post logo

It may be obsolete, but the loss of Miami Valley Centre is still upsetting

October 6, 2020

Thinking in Print: Malls are dying, and it’s a shame

By Charlene Pepiot | For The Post

W ait, malls are still a thing? Yes, but barely. Online shopping has made malls obsolete, and one in four are expected to close by 2022.

The Miami Valley Centre Mall in Piqua is no exception to the industry's decline. While its doors remain open, over the past five years, many of the shops within have been shuttered. What remains today is a sad sight.

The most recent casualty of closure is JCPenney — the only store still standing amid the empty cement spaces where Elder Beerman, Sears, FYE and GNC once stood.

Inside, JCPenney is uncomfortably spacious as display stands, clothes racks and tables that once filled the store and drew in customers are emptied and shoved into corners with “fixture for sale” stickers. A circular room whose shelves held bath towels, silverware and crock pots now lies empty, as the dwindling stock rests on a single table placed outside the entrance. Every clothes rack boasts a sign calculating prices after the 70%-90% discount is applied.

There is something tragic in seeing what used to be such a lively place in the community be hollowed out and sold off with little thought. JCPenney has operated in Piqua since 1922 and moved into the mall in 1988. Piqua customers have come to rely on JCPenney has a source of clothing and home commodities with a large variety that smaller stores lack. With Elder-Beerman also gone, local consumers in need of nice clothes are left with the lower-quality Walmart off-brands and the small selections from less prominent stores.

It is sad to watch the employees call for backup at registers as the checkout line lengthens, knowing in a matter of weeks they will be out of work in the middle of a pandemic. Nobody should have to suffer through this unemployed, but that’s the reality Piqua’s JCPenney employees are facing.

It is the smaller stores lining the main walkway that are the life of the mall. Most have flyers limiting the capacity for COVID-19, though the minimal number of shoppers present renders the rule obsolete. With JCPenny closing, the mall loses the traffic of the large anchor store’s loyal shoppers and the smaller businesses that rely on exposure from said traffic suffer. Dunham’s Sports is currently the only anchor store left in the mall, and the appeal of sport’s equipment is bound to attract fewer customers than the combined forces of it, Elder Beerman, Sears and JCPenney in the mall’s prime.

The mall’s white floors are polished, the black trash cans stand empty and the trees remain pruned. The food court with its checkerboard tables and multiple hand sanitizer bottles is as inviting as ever. The mall is welcoming, clean and pristine. All it’s missing is people to breathe life into these otherwise generic items.

Sadly, with COVID-19 discouraging in-store shopping, there’s little chance of people turning against Amazon to come back any time soon. Malls may be obsolete, but the impact of their loss will be felt regardless, and that’s no different for the Miami Valley Centre Mall.

Charlene Pepiot is a junior studying English at Ohio University. Please note that the views and opinions of the columnists do not reflect those of The Post. Want to talk more about it? Let Charlene know by emailing her


AUTHOR: Charlene Pepiot
EDITOR: Noah Wright
COPY EDITOR: Bre Offenberger